When the Kidnapper Interrogates His Own Victims | The Case of Alisa Mathewson

By Unseen .May 31, 2024

Unseen .

Driven by the belief that there’s always more to the story, Unseen delves beyond the headlines to uncover the quiet resilience, courage, and humanity at the heart of real cases. With a focus on the untold and the overlooked, Unseen shines a light on what’s often left in the shadows, creating moments of connection and understanding.

Follow:

New members can try it for free – Visit https://Audible.com/unseen or text code ‘unseen’ to 500-500 for a free trial of Audible. Callers receive a text; message and data rates apply.

March 11th 2017 – 14-year-old Arden Summers drives her younger siblings back to her mother's home, following her dad’s secret orders. Hours later, an employee of a nearby Walgreens calls 911 after seeing a tied up woman run out of a car: the woman is Alisa Mathewson – Arden’s mom. Before the police can arrive, the car drives away with Alisa. Nobody knows where they are heading to, and with who, but Arden, who is home alone with her other siblings, might be able to solve the case in time.

Credits:

Directed, Written, and Edited by Hannah Duncan

Researched by Tianyi Zhang

Voiceover by William Akana

Produced by Alexandra Salois & Salim Sader

External Footage:

CBS

48 Hours - Alisa Mathewson’s Night Terrors

Law&Crime Network

Watch Live: FL v. Trevor Summers - Dad On Trial For Kidnapping, Attempted Murder Of Mom

Watch Live: FL v. Trevor Summers - Dad On Trial For Kidnapping, Attempted Murder Of Mom Day 1 Part 2

Watch Live: FL v. Trevor Summers - Dad On Trial For Kidnapping, Attempted Murder Of Mom Day 2 CONFESSION: Trevor Summers Admits to Tying Up Ex-Wife, Being 'Manipulative'

Defendant Asks Judge If He Can Represent Himself Mid-Trial

Man Cross-Examines Ex-Wife Who Accused Him of Kidnapping, Trying to Murder Her

Ex-Wife Testifies Kidnapper Husband Said 'This Is What Love Is' When He Sliced His Own Throat

‘You Raped Me!’: Woman Confronts Ex-Husband During Surprise Cross-Examination

'I Put the Pillow on Her Face': Police Interview Accused Kidnapper

Trevor Summers Trevor Summers Guilty of ALL CHARGES in Kidnapping, Attempted Murder, and Sexual Assault of Ex-Wife Trevor Summers Sentenced to Life in Prison for Kidnapping, Attempted Murder of Ex-Wife

FOX 13 Tampa Bay

Daughter to testify against father accused of kidnapping, raping estranged wife

Florida man accused of kidnapping estranged wife wants another new attorney

Trevor Summers grills ex-wife in Florida courtroom as attempted murder trial gets underway

Kidnapped woman: 'Prayers got me through it'

Florida man accused of kidnapping estranged wife wants another new attorney

Inside Edition

Husband Accused of Rape, Kidnapping Cross-Examines Ex-Wife

WFLA News Channel 8

Alisa Summers speaks out

Kidnapped Valrico mother found alive

Alisa Mathewson

My Story for Marcy's Law Clarity on 48 hours episode additional information

Matt Orchard -Crime and Society

He Who Defends Himself: The Legal Manoeuvres of Trevor Summers

Motion Array

Getty Images

For more stories like this, subscribe to our YouTube here

*********************

Music License: MB014SJDMBMUVY9 Music Content ID: Identifyy

Up next

- YouTube

Killer Thinks He Got Away - Doesn't Know 4YO Saw Everything | The Case of Dameon Huffman

“My grandparents were lying in bed, melted”

By Unseen .May 07, 2025

Unseen .

Driven by the belief that there’s always more to the story, Unseen delves beyond the headlines to uncover the quiet resilience, courage, and humanity at the heart of real cases. With a focus on the untold and the overlooked, Unseen shines a light on what’s often left in the shadows, creating moments of connection and understanding.

At 9:15AM on March 23rd, 2007, a 4-year-old arrives at his church daycare alone, wearing his pajamas and out of breath. Following his next words, his teacher immediately calls 911. Something terrible has just happened in the rural community of Bradford, and Dameon Huffman, the 4-year-old boy, is the only witness to the horrors. Little do police know that what little Dameon saw was actually one of the most twisted cases of home invasion gone wrong that the state of Ohio has ever known, and he will be key to understanding what really happened to Jack and Linda Myers.

Credits
Written, directed & edited by Matthew Rice
Researched by Manon Lafosse
Voiceover by William Akana
Produced by Alexandrs Salois & Salim Sader

For more stories like this, subscribe to our YouTube here

********************
Sources:
“The Green Monster”, American Monster, Discovery+, 2017 (Arrow Media)
“A Dragon in the Farmhouse”, In Ice Cold Blood, Oxygen Network, 2021. (Asylum Entertainment & Final Level Entertainment)
“The Green Dragon”, On the Case with Paula Zahn: Discovery+, 2014. (Investigation Discovery & Scott Sternberg Productions, Inc.) “The Green Dragon”, Solved: Investigation Discovery, 2009 (Digital Ranch)
“In the Bag”, Forensic Files: Film Rise & Tru TV, 2008, (Medstar Television)
“Greg Must Choose Life In Prison or Death”, Red Tree Stories: Youtube, 2023 (Youtube)

- YouTube

solving a murder

Killer Thinks He Got Away — Until She Gets Revenge | The Case of Christie Wilson & Debbie Boyd

“I may be 5ft1 and blonde, but I’m a barracuda”

By Unseen .Apr 30, 2025

Unseen .

Driven by the belief that there’s always more to the story, Unseen delves beyond the headlines to uncover the quiet resilience, courage, and humanity at the heart of real cases. With a focus on the untold and the overlooked, Unseen shines a light on what’s often left in the shadows, creating moments of connection and understanding.

At 1:13 AM on the morning of October 5th, 2005, Christie Wilson is captured on a casino parking lot CCTV, walking next to a mysterious figure. The rotating camera takes 3 minutes and 40 seconds to complete its next turn, but in those minutes something terrible happens hidden in the dark, and Christie disappears. It's up to her parents, Debbie and Pat Boyd, to bring their daughter home, and do whatever it takes to catch this dangerous man, and finally put an end to his killing spree.

Credits
Directed, written & edited by Alexandre Gendron & Maxime Desrochers
Curated by Tanvi Rajvanshi
Researched by Manon Lafosse
Voiceover by William Akana
Produced by Alexandra Salois & Salim Sader

For more stories like this, subscribe to our YouTube here

********************

Sources
CBS
Oxygen True Crime
Anatomy of Murder
Medstar Television
Arrow International Media

- YouTube

Killer Thinks He Got Away – Doesn’t Know She Escaped the Box | The Case of Brook Weber

"When you cross the line, you pay for it"

By Unseen .Apr 30, 2025

Unseen .

Driven by the belief that there’s always more to the story, Unseen delves beyond the headlines to uncover the quiet resilience, courage, and humanity at the heart of real cases. With a focus on the untold and the overlooked, Unseen shines a light on what’s often left in the shadows, creating moments of connection and understanding.

Brook Weber is just 18 years old in August of 1996 when she and her boyfriend Jeffrey Wolfe find themselves in the most disturbing home in all of Mississippi. Gary Carl Simmons, a local butcher in Moss Pointe, has been waiting for someone like Brook to fall into his clutches after his ex-wife Lori Simmons fled with their children in fear of her life. In fact, Gary has a perfect human-sized box hidden in his house, waiting to make his fantasies come to life. Little does Gary know that the Butcher’s Box is no match for Brook, and with a little luck and a lot of skill, not only will she escape, but she’ll make him pay for his crimes.
Credits:
Directed, written, & edited by Justin Chalifoux
Curated by Tianyi Zhang
Research by Tiffany Loxton
Voiceover by William Akana
Produced by Alexandra Salois & Salim Sader
For more stories like this, subscribe to our YouTube here

********************

Sources

Shattered: The Box (Red Marble Media)

Evil Lives Here: Butcher and the Box (Red Marble Media)

The Horrific Crimes of Gary Simmons (Vocal Media)

- YouTube

Mom Kills Millionaire CEO – Doesn’t Know They Filmed This | The Case of Ben Novack Jr

“Only a monster can do this kind of evil thing”

By Unseen .Apr 10, 2025

Unseen .

Driven by the belief that there’s always more to the story, Unseen delves beyond the headlines to uncover the quiet resilience, courage, and humanity at the heart of real cases. With a focus on the untold and the overlooked, Unseen shines a light on what’s often left in the shadows, creating moments of connection and understanding.

Use UNSEEN to get 55% off your first month at Scentbird: https://sbird.co/3CYwasq

This month we received...

Sugarful by Michel Germain https://sbird.co/4h6Hq40

Twin Flame by 5 Sens https://sbird.co/43gW70T

103 Tiare flower Hibiscus Jasmine by Bon Parfumeur https://sbird.co/4hTCOzj

Juice Expressive by COMMODITY https://sbird.co/41xrza4

On the morning of July 12, 2009, in the Rye Brook Hilton Hotel, May Abad receives a frantic call from hotel security, urging her to rush to her parents’ suite. As she races down the hallway, her mother, Narcy Novack’s, screams cut through the silence—her father, Ben Novack Jr., millionaire and heir to Miami’s famous Fontainebleau hotel, has been brutally murdered. Now, May is on a desperate hunt for the truth. But what she doesn’t realize is that the killer is much closer than she ever imagined.

Credits

Directed & edited by Matthew Rice

Writing & research by Bianca Yzabelle Tan

Revisions by Kat Gardilcic

Produced by Alexandra Salois & Salim Sader

Voiceover by William Akana

For more stories like this, subscribe to our YouTube here

********************

Sources

Dateline NBC, “Family Affair”

CNBC, Deadly Rich, “Bound for Murder”

48 Hours, “Crazy Love”

Dying to Belong, “Narcy Novack”

The Criminal Mind Unveiled, “My Dirty Little Secret”

- YouTube

He only targets cheerleaders | The Case of Retha Stratton

“There’s a monster out there”

By Unseen .Mar 31, 2025

Unseen .

Driven by the belief that there’s always more to the story, Unseen delves beyond the headlines to uncover the quiet resilience, courage, and humanity at the heart of real cases. With a focus on the untold and the overlooked, Unseen shines a light on what’s often left in the shadows, creating moments of connection and understanding.

Go to https://PIAVPN.com/Unseen to get 83% off Private Internet Access with 4 months free!

It’s 1981 in the sleepy town of River Oaks, Texas, and someone is hunting cheerleaders. A 16-year-old teenager, Susan Brown, is brutally attacked in her own home. What she, the cops, and the rest of the town don’t know is that she’s just the first victim in a rampage that will change this Texas suburb forever. One by one, members of the Castleberry High School cheer squad are targeted, but things escalate when Rona Stratton’s sister is found dead in her bedroom. Rona decides to team up with her friend Lisa Ticknor, who also survived an attack, along with the other cheerleaders in the squad, to start a decades-long fight to take down the Cheerleader Slayer, and make sure he would never hurt anyone else.

#PrivateInternetAccess #vpn #PIA #bestvpnapp

Directed, written & edited by Alexandre Gendron

Research by Manon Lafosse

Voiceover by William Akana

Produced by Alexandra Salois & Salim Sader

For more stories like this, subscribe to our YouTube here

********************

Sources

Discovery +

Warner Bros

CBS News

The portal to Texas History

Channel 5 Action News

KXAS-TV

The Digital Library

Channel 5 Action News

KXAS-TV

British Pathé

Watch More

Killer Thinks He Got Away Until Cops Find Secret Footage | The Case of Patrick de la Cerda

- YouTube

solving a murder

Killer Thinks He Got Away Until Cops Find Secret Footage | The Case of Patrick de la Cerda

9 YO Escapes Her Dad’s Death Cult — Avenges All Victims | The Case Of Jenn Carson

- YouTube

9 YO Escapes Her Dad’s Death Cult — Avenges All Victims | The Case Of Jenn Carson

“Alpha” Killer Thinks He Got Away — Doesn’t Know Ex is ALIVE | The Case of Meghan Verikas

- YouTube

“Alpha” Killer Thinks He Got Away — Doesn’t Know Ex is ALIVE | The Case of Meghan Verikas

Family Feud Killer Thinks He Can Get Away With It | The Case of Becky Bliefnick

- YouTube

solving a murder

Family Feud Killer Thinks He Can Get Away With It | The Case of Becky Bliefnick

Santa Claus Thinks He Got Away– Doesn’t Know 8 YO Survived | The Covina Christmas Massacre

- YouTube

Santa Claus Thinks He Got Away– Doesn’t Know 8 YO Survived | The Covina Christmas Massacre

How Every Cop Should Interrogate Kids | The Case of the Real Mindhunter

- YouTube

solving a murder

How Every Cop Should Interrogate Kids | The Case of the Real Mindhunter

Ex-Cop Grandma Comes Out Of Retirement To Catch Daughter’s Killer | The Case of Krystal Mitchell

- YouTube

solving a murder

Ex-Cop Grandma Comes Out Of Retirement To Catch Daughter’s Killer | The Case of Krystal Mitchell

Cops Think Step-Mom Killed Dad – Until 6YO Reveals This Clue | The Case of the Oxley Family

- YouTube

solving a murder

Cops Think Step-Mom Killed Dad – Until 6YO Reveals This Clue | The Case of the Oxley Family

12 YO Escapes Death Cult Minutes Before Massacre | The Case of Tracy Parks

12 YO Escapes Death Cult Minutes Before Massacre | The Case of Tracy Parks